Handcrafted since 1947
Our Ice Cream
Small-batch, made-from-scratch ice cream using fresh dairy and real ingredients. Every scoop tells a story.
Our Story
What Makes Our Ice Cream Taste So Good?
Our 40+ flavors of ice cream are always deliciously creamy and decadent. All of our premium ice creams and premium honey ice creams contain 14% butterfat and minimal air. The leading national brands generally contain far less fat and much more air, creating a product that’s less rich. We also use freshly frozen fruits, fine purees, real peanut butter, quality nuts, fine chocolates, and real vanilla to create our unique flavor blends. When you purchase Hall’s Ice Cream, you have our guarantee that it will be fresh and that it will meet your expectations of quality & flavor. Our products are also PA Preferred®, so you can feel good about supporting Pennsylvania farmers. Just look for the logo on our packaging!
Over 79 years later, we still make every batch the same way — with real ingredients, no shortcuts, and the same dedication to quality that John instilled from day one. That's the Hall's difference.
Made the Old-Fashioned Way
At Hall's, we've been making ice cream the same way since John Allen Hall first started in 1947 — with fresh dairy, real fruit, and no shortcuts. Every batch is crafted in small quantities so you always get the freshest, creamiest scoop possible.
We offer a large variety of flavors, including our signature honey-sweetened varieties that set us apart from every other ice cream you've tried. Stop in and ask what's fresh!
Varieties & Flavors
We offer several different varieties of premium ice cream, premium honey ice cream, premium no sugar added ice cream, sherbet, dixie cups, and doggy treats. All of our products are made with quality ingredients in 10 gallon batches to ensure superior taste & texture. Our honey ice creams are made with 8% PA Preferred honey in cooperation with the PA Beekeepers’ Association. Our 6 oz Dixie Cups are perfect for individual servings. Our doggy treats are a lowfat dairy product in a 6 oz cup with a dog bone on top. Please note that all flavors are not available at all times.
AVAILABLE IN NO SUGAR ADDED|Available in Dixie Cups (Available in other flavors with 2 weeks notice)
Classic Ice Cream
Banana
Birch Beer
Black Cherry
Black Cherry Vanilla
Black Cherry Walnut
Black Walnut
Blueberry
Butter Krunch
Butter Pecan
Butterscotch
Cherry Vanilla
Chocolate
Chocolate Almond
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Malt
Chocolate Marshmallow
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Cinnamon
Coconut Custard
Coffee
Cookie
Cookie Dough (3 gal. or 5 qt. bucket)
Dark Chocolate
Fort Hunter
French Vanilla
Grape Nut
Irish Creame
Lemon Custard
"Love 99" Malted Munchie
Maple Walnut
Mint Chocolate Chip
Monkey Butter
Orange Pineapple
Peach
Peanut Butter
Pineapple
Root Beer
Salted Caramel
Strawberry
Teaberry
Tin Roof (not available in pints)
Tracks (not available in pints)
Vanilla
Vanilla Fudge
Vanilla/Orange Sherbert (not available in pints)
Honey Sweetened
Butter Pecan
Chocolate
Cinnamon
Raspberry
Vanilla
Seasonal Specials
Candy Cane Ice Cream
Cranberry Sherbert
Honey Flavored Pumpkin Ice Cream
Pumpkin Ice Cream
Sundaes & Specialties
Build a perfect sundae or treat yourself to one of our house specialties.
Banana Split
Your choice of ice cream available in two sizes. Banana and ice cream topped with chocolate syrup, marshmallow crinkle, crushed pineapple, peanuts, whipped cream, and a cherry.
CMP Sundae
Your choice of ice cream available in three sizes. Topped with chocolate syrup, marshmallow crinkle, and peanuts.
Cones & Dishes
Your choice of ice cream available in four sizes. Sprinkles available.
Floats
Made with your choice of root beer or other available soda and topped with your choice of ice cream.
Milkshakes
Made extra thick from your choice of ice cream. Malt available.
One Topping Sundae
Your choice of ice cream available in three sizes. Topped with your choice of one of our available toppings. Extra toppings available.
Pup Cups
A low=fat treat for your four-legged friends — vanilla or peanut butter, just for dogs. Topped with a dog bone.
Strawberry Sundae
Your choice of ice cream available in three sizes. Topped with fresh frozen strawberries.
Available Toppings
- Caramel
- Cherries
- Chocolate Syrup
- Crushed Pineapple
- Hot Fudge
- Marshmallow Crinkle
- Peanut Butter
- Peanuts
- Sprinkles
- Strawberries
- Wet Walnuts
A Note on Our Flavors
Our flavor lineup rotates with the seasons and availability of fresh ingredients. Not every flavor is available every day — call ahead or stop in to see what's fresh. We also take special orders for events and weddings.
Come Try a Scoop
Find Hall's Homestyle Ice Cream at our shop in Millerstown or at a retailer near you across Central Pennsylvania.